Dr Hilary Cass has said she does not support the current wording of a draft bill aimed at banning conversion practices, warning that it could create “serious unintended consequences” for parents and therapists working with young people. Her intervention adds a significant voice to a debate that sits at the intersection of gender care, child safeguarding, clinical practice and equality law.
Dr Hilary Cass is the author of the independent review into gender identity services for children and young people in England, a process known as the Cass Review. The review has become a central reference point in discussions about how health systems should respond to children and adolescents experiencing gender-related distress, particularly where medical, psychological and family considerations overlap.
The issue raised by Cass concerns the legal boundary between banning coercive practices and preserving space for careful therapeutic work. Conversion practices are generally understood as efforts to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. Cass’s concern is that, if the draft bill is framed too broadly, ordinary clinical exploration or parental conversations could be treated as unlawful, even when they are not coercive and are intended to support a young person’s wellbeing.
The warning is likely to be closely watched by clinicians, policymakers and advocacy groups in the United Kingdom. Proposals to outlaw conversion practices have drawn broad support in principle, especially where they target abusive or coercive conduct. The challenge for lawmakers is how to draft a ban that protects people from harm while avoiding uncertainty for professionals who are expected to assess complex cases, discuss options and involve families where appropriate.
Cass’s position does not amount to opposition to protecting people from conversion practices. Her objection is directed at the bill’s wording and the practical effects it could have on parents and therapists. That distinction is central to the next phase of the debate: whether legislators can produce language that is precise enough to prohibit harmful conduct without discouraging responsible clinical care or ordinary family support.


