Reactions to MLB trade deadline deals

The 2026 MLB trade deadline is quickly approaching, with contending teams deciding what they need to add before 6 p.m. ET on Monday. This is the place to find out the fantasy baseball implications as a result of the major wheeling and dealing.

Editor’s Picks

2 Related

The biggest domino, of course, fell late Saturday night when the Los Angeles Dodgers acquired Tarik Skubal from the Detroit Tigers. Other big names that potentially could be on the move include Mason Miller, Hunter Goodman and Byron Buxton. Of course, surprising moves are also on the table, so be sure to check back here should any unexpected moves transpire.

Every season’s trade deadline has its own unique set of answers and repercussions. Eric Karabell and Tristan H. Cockcroft will analyze and provide an outlook for all of the key players on the move, as well as new opportunities that may arise from those left behind when all the dust has settled.

Note: Not every transaction warrants the attention of fantasy managers, but for those trades that do merit analysis, you’ll find them listed below.

Philadelphia Phillies trade for 1B/2B/DH Luis Arraez and RP Caleb Killian

Karabell (Aug. 3): Desperate for offensive aid and a setup reliever, the Phillies achieve these objectives in a trade with the San Francisco Giants for prospects. The nomadic Arraez, a three-time batting champion (and with three different franchises), joins his fifth team in the past five seasons. Arraez is one of the most unique players in baseball, as what he lacks in power he makes up for with extreme contact. Only 13 hitters boast more fantasy points this season. Arraez, a career .318 hitter, is already a points-league star and this trade aids his value.

Not known for his defensive prowess, Arraez has played a surprisingly excellent second base this season. However, Bryson Stott handles second base in Philadelphia. The Phillies may make room by moving a willing Bryce Harper back to the outfield, which he hasn’t played since 2022. They may move Stott to third base, and Alec Bohm to first. Perhaps another trade is pending. The DH spot is capably filled by Kyle Schwarber. Regardless, expect Arraez to bat in one of the top two spots in the lineup and produce at a high level, as always.

Killian, 29, led the Giants with eight saves, but his role adjusts with the Phillies, as RHP Jhoan Duran is entrenched as closer. Killian should assume top setup duties in conjunction with LHP Brooks Raley (acquired in a trade this morning from the New York Mets). While Killian’s run prevention has been merely average, he should see ample chances for holds. Killian may have more value with the Phillies than he did with the floundering Giants. The Giants may utilize LHP Erik Miller or RHP Keaton Winn in their now-open closer role.

Toronto Blue Jays trade for SP Jose Soriano

Cockcroft (Aug. 3): AL East teams have been making some strange moves as the trade deadline nears. In addition to the Yankees’ acquisition of Luis Garcia Jr., who brings to them some roster redundancies, we now have the Blue Jays trading away one starting pitcher only to acquire two within the span of 36 hours. Soriano joins Jameson Taillon as new Blue Jays, though the ex-Los Angeles Angels right-hander is the considerably more relevant one for fantasy purposes.

Soriano’s acquisition makes sense in that he’s eight years younger and is signed for two more seasons than was Gausman — Gausman’s contract expires at year’s end, while Soriano is under team control through 2028 — so perhaps it’s a matter of the Blue Jays deciding to adapt the roster for 2027 while also staying competitive in this year’s wild-card race. They’re still only 4.5 games back, though they do have five teams ahead of them who are also currently below the cut. We shall see, as the Blue Jays’ deadline strategy has something to say about Soriano’s fantasy utility over the season’s final two months.

For now, assume the Blue Jays maintain their current core. In that case, Soriano joins a team with a significantly better bullpen, as the Blue Jays’ relief ERA is more than a half-run better than the Angels’ number, though their disappointing lineup has averaged MLB’s fewest runs per game (3.92), so run support might still prove a problem. Toronto’s Rogers Centre is similarly neutral overall to Los Angeles’ Angel Stadium, with a bit more of a home run lean, though Soriano is a ground-ball pitcher for whom that shouldn’t prove a big issue.

Soriano’s value should stay about the same, though bear in mind that he’s not the pitcher who posted an 0.84 ERA across his first seven starts this season. That number is 4.59 over his last 15, so it’s probably best to expect something in the 3.50-4.00 range going forward. That’s better than a streaming option, but not by a whole lot.

Arjun Nimmala, the Blue Jays’ No. 2 prospect in Kiley McDaniel’s July update, has dealt with injuries and inconsistency this year but could be a factor for the Angels by 2028. Edward Micheletti and Angel Rivero also went to the Angels in the deal.

Chicago Cubs trade for SP Kevin Gausman

Cockcroft (Aug. 2): Needing to address their injury-depleted rotation, the Cubs will acquire Gausman, who since the beginning of 2021 has the second-most starts (181), innings pitched (1,053) and fourth-most quality starts (100) in the league. Though never a 15-win (or better) pitcher or top-two finisher in the Cy Young balloting in any of his 13 previous big-league seasons, Gausman has been a plenty reliable starter, both for fantasy and the on-field game.

Gausman is now 35 years old and coming off a shaky stretch that has seen him post a 6.47 ERA in his most recent eight starts, so fantasy managers might understandably hesitate to count on a rebound from him. But he he still generates a good share of swings and misses with his signature splitter, and his 3.33 ERA against sub-.500 teams demonstrates that his worst-case fantasy scenario should be at least that of a matchups pitcher. A drawback to the trade, however, is that the Cubs have one of the game’s toughest remaining schedules, so the smart play is to assume that what we’ve seen from Gausman to this point will probably be his valuation moving forward.

That’s still a pitcher who warrants a hefty NL-only bid, if you play in those formats, and a 20-25% of your annual budget bid makes sense if you can’t get one of the bigger prizes (Skubal thus far, and we’ll see what else transpires before 6 p.m. ET Monday). Gausman is also available in more than 15% of ESPN leagues.

The Blue Jays acquired a pair of prospects, Class-A shortstop Ty Southisene and Triple-A outfielder Brett Bateman, in the deal. Both are players who derive most of their value from their speed, and only Bateman is relatively close to the majors, perhaps with a September cup of coffee or early 2027 ETA.

New York Yankees trade for 2B/1B Luis Garcia Jr.

Cockcroft (Aug. 2): In a bit of a square-peg-in-round-hole move, the Yankees acquired Garcia from the Washington Nationals in exchange for four players. Garcia has been a plenty productive hitter this season, placing fifth among second base and 10th among first base eligibles in ESPN leagues, but his defense at both spots has been historically suspect. The Yankees can certainly use his bat, but they’re already well-stocked at any of the three most likely defensive positions where he should slot: First base (Ben Rice/Paul Goldschmidt), designated hitter (Rice and eventually Giancarlo Stanton) and second base (Jazz Chisholm Jr.).

We’ll see whether the Yankees have other moves to make, but it’s difficult to avoid worry about all of those players’ at-bats moving forward. Garcia will almost assuredly become the strong-side first base platoon partner for Goldschmidt, which decreases each of their daily fantasy utility to a degree, and Rice will almost assuredly shift to DH and could become a strong-side platoon partner there once Stanton returns, again costing each player some starts. It’s also difficult to look at this deal and not wonder whether the Yankees are worried about how much injured outfielders Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger might give them the rest of the regular season, and that this is a trade to help bolster the offense wherever they might find it.

At least Yankee Stadium’s lefty-friendly confines should help Garcia maintain what has been a career-best power pace. His 23 home runs, 12.6% Barrel and 45.8% hard hit rates are all personal bests, and Yankee Stadium is significantly better for lefty power than Washington’s Nationals Park. Garcia will be a matchups must-start when playing home games against righties, and note that he has a career OPS 178 points higher against righties than lefties for his career. So, perhaps he’s more of a “roundish-square” peg, but it’s still somewhat puzzling considering the Yankees’ current roster construct.

Among the four players the Nationals received in return, Jake Bird and Yovanny Cruz have major league experience and can fill roles in what has been a largely wide-open Nationals bullpen, though neither should be added in fantasy leagues until one proves himself over several games. Two pitching-prospect fliers were also included: Jack Cebert, who has put forth a 4.03 ERA and 27.4% strikeout rate across 14 starts and two relief appearances between Class A and Double-A ball, and Ben Grable, who throws hard but is a relief prospect in Double-A. Either could be a factor for the big club a year from now.

Tampa Bay Rays acquire SP Freddy Peralta

Cockcroft (Aug. 2): A relative disappointment in his four-plus months with the New York Mets, Peralta now joins a Rays organization that is highly regarded for its ability to coax the most out of its pitchers, meaning fantasy owners are probably giddy to hear about the move — especially those with mountains of FAB resources with which to bid in AL-only leagues. (Yes, you should spend a good chunk of it in those, arguably in the 40%-of-seasonal-budget range.)

While it’s true that the Rays do squeeze a lot from their pitchers, especially those joining them on a down note, a closer look at the results show that it’s hardly an automatic. Nick Martinez, Zach Eflin and Rich Hill were excellent acquisitions for them, but Steven Matz, Aaron Civale and Luis Patino were unqualified disasters, among more notable pickups they made since the end of the 2020 season. It’s dangerous, therefore, to leap to an assumption that Peralta will spring back to his career-best, fifth-in-the-National-League-in-Cy-Young-balloting form from last season, simply because he’ll be putting on a Rays uniform. That’s a common assumption in the fantasy biz; it’s also not the seamless truth people seem to think it is.

Buuuuuut … the Rays do play in one of baseball’s best pitching homes in Tropicana Field, and they have one of the league’s better bullpens, with a league-leading 44 saves and a 12th-ranked 3.89 relief ERA, so this is indeed one of the best places Peralta could’ve possibly landed. If the Rays could coax even a tick of restoration of Peralta’s lost fastball velocity, or if they ask him to lean more on his whiff-generating breaking pitches, perhaps he’ll come close to his former form. It’s certainly worth taking the chance in fantasy leagues, and note that Peralta is still out there as a free agent in nearly 28% of ESPN leagues.

On the Mets side, they acquired three prospects: OF Aidan Smith, SP Gary Gill Hill and 2B Emilen Pitre. None was one of the team’s top prospects, with Smith considered the best of the trio but also the furthest from the majors. Hill and/or Pitre could become factors sometime next year, with the latter possessing an intriguing combination of speed and plate discipline.

Peralta’s departure, by the way, presents a clearer rest-of-year rotational path for prospect Zac Thornton, and it could increase the chances we’ll see additional starts for Jonah Tong. Either might have some streaming value in the right matchup.

Chicago White Sox trade for SP Luis Castillo

Cockcroft (Aug. 2): The White Sox, still very much a legitimate postseason contender and possessing a three-game lead in the American League Central, acquired much-needed starting pitching help from the Seattle Mariners in Castillo. Though no longer the elite starter he once was — he was baseball’s fifth best-scoring pitcher as recently as 2023 — Castillo has at least settled into the skill set he now possesses (2 mph less fastball velocity and 10% fewer whiffs with his slider), posting a 4.04 ERA across eight starts and three relief appearances since the Mariners bumped him from their regular rotation and into a piggyback arrangement with their other starters.

Castillo seems to have settled in as a streaming-capable starter, having delivered some of his better starts recently against weaker offenses (CLE, TOR, CIN), and should continue to do so for his new team. The only drawback is that he’s leaving arguably baseball’s best home pitching environment in Seattle’s T-Mobile Park, though Chicago’s Rate Field leans slightly pitching-friendly with a similar three-year home run factor (the part of the game that’s most concerning for the fly ball-oriented righty).

The Mariners, also a postseason contender but facing more of a climb, received reliever Seranthony Dominguez, who poses almost no threat to closer Andres Munoz’s job security and will mainly pad the team’s depth. Nolan Jones — yes, that same Colorado Rockies one-year wonder, now settled as Triple-A depth — and catching prospect Boston Smith, who has had an excellent year in the minors and is now in Double-A ball, also went Seattle’s way.

Curtis Mead traded from the Nationals to the Red Sox for Connelly Early

Karabell (July 27): Fantasy managers (especially in AL-only formats) enjoyed a weekend gift with the Boston Red Sox acquiring 1B/3B Curtis Mead from the Washington Nationals for LHP Connelly Early. The trade makes sense for both clubs.

The Nationals desperately covet young pitching, and Early — with a 3.44 ERA and 23.8% strikeout rate in 17 starts — should join the rotation in the coming weeks when he returns from an IL stint due to elbow inflammation. Even if Early is healthy, fantasy managers may want to be careful in assuming he pitches to prior levels with his new team. The Nationals also have major bullpen issues, for those who selfishly want their starting pitchers to actually win contests.

Mead, however, despite joining his fourth organization in the past two seasons, has been more impactful for fantasy managers and should continue to pile on fantasy points. Mead, 25, ranks among the top 50 hitters in fantasy points this season, yet he is rostered in only 21.3% of ESPN leagues. He is far more valuable in more traditional formats that utilize a corner infield spot. Mead, a right-handed hitter, boasts an .817 OPS versus right-handed pitching, an 11.9% walk rate and a 48.7% pull rate. He should particularly enjoy hitting at Fenway Park.

In addition, the Red Sox figure to employ Mead at second base, which is further great news for fantasy managers, as he will add eligibility there soon (he is currently up to six games at 2B). In typical leagues, multi-position eligibility is critical. We shall see where Mead hits in the lineup for his expected debut Monday night, but it figures to be near the top. After all, 1B Willson Contreras is the lone Red Sox hitter with either a better OPS or more home runs for the season. This trade makes Mead more appealing in fantasy.