In a growing conflict that exposes the relationship between government institutions, the Vatican has officially expressed concerns over decisions made by French authorities in the case of the dismissal of a nun, citing violations of religious freedom. This global disagreement revolves around the situation of Sabine de la Valette, Sister Marie Ferréol and her expulsion, from the Dominican Sisters of the Holy Spirit.
The Vatican, represented by Matteo Bruni, director of its Press Office, officially recognized that it was handling this matter through means. A formal communication has been sent to the French Embassy in the Vatican in a gesture that underlines the seriousness with which the Vatican views the intrusion of the French legal system into what it considers to be purely religious and internal affairs of the Church Catholic.
The dispute arose when the Lorient court reportedly rendered a judgment on the religious aspects of Ms. De la Valettes’ exit from her religious community. The Vatican expressed its disapproval of the decision, implying that it had been informed of the court’s role through media coverage rather than through formal channels involving a breakdown in transparency or communication between French officials and the Holy See.
Cardinal Marc Ouellet, who was part of the case, as prefect of the Congregation for Bishops, would have received no notification from the Lorient court concerning this affair. Bruni mentioned that Cardinal Ouellet made a visit to the institute as part of his duties, which resulted in proceedings being filed against Ms. De la Valette ultimately leading to her dismissal.
The Vatican says that if the Lorient Tribunal makes a decision, it will raise immunity concerns on this issue and could infringe on the right to freely worship and associate with others. These rights are guaranteed by laws that generally affirm that religious organizations have the right to manage their affairs independently, without outside intervention.
The recent event has sparked debate about how national legal systems and religious laws intersect and the role of courts in regulating religious groups. Opponents of the court’s decision suggest that it sets a standard of interference with religious freedom, which could impact not only the Catholic Church but also other faith-based organizations seeking autonomy, in the face of external pressures.
As this scenario unfolds, it presents legal obstacles that underscore the ongoing debate over defining the boundaries between church independence and governmental jurisdiction in modern societies. The outcome of this affair could have various consequences on relations between France and the Vatican as well as on the broader subject of religious freedoms across Europe.
As Massimo Introvigne said in a recent article: “it seems that attacks on religious freedom are now daily in France”.
source link eu news
